Chris
Brown and Dating Violence
By Jack Schmidt
“It’s not
a sound bite. This is a real situation. If you can’t have compassion
for others, just imagine it being your sister or your mom or someone
like that. Then think about how you should talk about that.”
- Jay – Z, February
16th, 2009
“It’s so
devastating. As a person, I don’t care how famous she is or if she
just worked at McDonald’s, that should never happen. It should never
come to that place.”
- Kanye West, February
10th, 2009
The incident
that occurred between Chris Brown and Rihanna on the evening of February
8th, 2009 has been widely discussed in the media and in general.
The basic facts are that celebrity and singer Chris Brown turned himself
in to the Los Angeles police regarding an alleged assault of a woman.
Since then, it has become widely assumed/known that the woman he allegedly
assaulted was his girlfriend, fellow celebrity and singer Rihanna.
Since then, numerous public reactions have followed, songs have been
pulled from airplay, endorsements have been dropped, rumors have spread,
and celebrities from the entertainment and music industry have commented
on the incident. The two quotes above represent two of those voices.
Both Kanye
West and Jay-Z are extremely successful. They are icons in the
hip hop industry, topping charts as well as enjoying commercial success.
They are known as producers and entrepreneurs, and are looked up to
as influential members of the music industry.
While both
their quotes obviously offer the desperately needed sympathy and support
for Rihanna, they also are both saying something a little more subtle,
but nevertheless just as necessary. Both quotes are drawing upon
the idea that while the Rihanna and Chris Brown dating violence incident
involves two famous, well known celebrities, intimate partner violence
is a problem for people from every walk of life. Jay-Z brings
up the point that this could happen to someone close to you, like “your
sister or your mom,” and Kanye points out how intimate partner violence
“should never happen,” even if someone is “famous or if she just
worked at McDonald’s.”
While I do
not agree with everything that Kanye or Jay-Z say, I do agree with them
on these two quotes. When we talk about the intimate partner violence
between Rihanna and Chris Brown we have to remember some things.
We have to remember that Rihanna is not alone and that there are many
women, children, and men who are victims or survivors of intimate partner
violence and we have to support them. According to the Department
of Justice, one in three women in America have been or will be abused.
We have to remember that no one ever deserves to be assaulted or victimized.
We have to remember that we are all affected by intimate partner violence
and we most likely know someone who is a survivor of an abusive relationship.
One interesting
aspect of this case is how Chris Brown in the past has openly talked
about the trauma he experienced as a youth from witnessing his stepfather
abuse his mother. In the words of Family Violence Prevention Fund
President Esta Soler, “if the allegations are true and he committed
this assault, we have to assume that he did not get the help he needed.”
However, Soler also notes that “nothing a victim does, and nothing
in a perpetrator’s background, ever justifies violence.” This
could possibly show the dangers and the harm in living in an environment
in which intimate partner violence occurs. It shows that we need
to have a more in-depth talk about violence in interpersonal relationships
in order to break the cycle, because we know that intimate partner violence
happens. Perhaps this cycle of violence is one of the most difficult
ideas when it comes to the case of Chris Brown. If the allegations
are true, it would be the case that he has continued the violence that
he was so strongly effected by as a youth. He has made statements
about how “sorry and saddened” he is. For Chris Brown, the
consequences do not end with his grief over his actions. If prosecuted
and sentenced, he could face possible jail time, and his career could
now be in jeopardy, as well as his contracts and endorsements.
Since violence
is a learned behavior, it can be unlearned. I hope that Chris
Brown is truly attempting to “emerge a better person” (http://www.spin.com/articles/chris-brown-sorry-and-saddened) with the help and support from his
family and friends. We can all imagine many things Chris Brown
could have done in that moment to prevent this violence from happening.
He could have gotten out of the car, he could have walked away, or he
could have expressed his anger in a vocal and non-threatening manner.
There are numerous examples from history from men who have found ways
to express themselves in a manner that does not use violence.
Just look at the great work and contributions to society from men like
Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. and Mahatma Gandhi. We must all realize
that violence is a choice, and we can always choose alternative ways
of expressing ourselves.
Furthermore,
we need to realize that everyone can do something to end intimate partner
violence as well. One way we can do this is by becoming educated
on the issue. We should all be offering our deepest sympathy and
support to Rihanna. And we should also be engaging in a deeper
discussion that Kanye and Jay-Z have addressed. Their comments
both illustrate a basic fact in regard to the Rihanna and Chris Brown
incident as well in general – that it is never the victim’s fault
and everyone deserves a life free of violence, no matter who you are.
For more
information regarding abusive relationships:
- STAND! Against Domestic
Violence: http://www.standagainstdv.org/index.php Crisis Line: 1-888-215-5555
- Community Violence
Solutions: http://www.cvsolutions.org/
- Marin Abused Women’s
Services, http://www.maws.org/
- Crisis Line English:
1-415-924-6616
- Crisis Line Spanish:
1-415-924-3456
- To find a program
near you: 1-800-799-SAFE
- Family Violence
Prevention Fund, http://www.endabuse.org/
- That’s Not Cool
Campaign, http://www.thatsnotcool.com/